Beer Brawl™ 25 – Pumpkin Beer

Seems like there are a lot of pumpkin beers out there now.  Is this the new American fall beer, like Oktoberfest is for Germany?  I hope not, this type of vegetable beer has only really been commercially made for the last 25 years or so.  Not a long history but as you’ll see a wide variety of flavors can be found with this type of beer from mildly seasoned to full on doughy pumpkin pie.BeerBrawl25_pumpkin

With me on this podcast was Mark Jackson, Corey Greenberg and Will Hogan.  The only prerequisite I have for the Beer Brawl™ is a love of beer.  You don’t need to know anything about the beers we are drinking only a willingness to try them and voice an opinion.

As usual we have a podcast of The Beer Brawl™ ready for download:

Listen to the Podcast

or download from iTunes

Subscribe to Podcast thru iTunes

On Tap:

  • Post Road Pumpkin Ale
  • Wolaver’s Will Steven’s Pumpkin Ale
  • Dogfish Head Punkin Ale
  • Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale
  • Southern Tier Imperial Pumking

As when we did our fruit beer Beer Brawl™, I was not thrilled with doing this episode.  I’m just not a fan of fruit or vegetable beers on a broad scale.  But, sometimes there are hidden gems or diamonds in the rough.  I always tell people to try new beer, how will you know you don’t like it until you try it?  So I need to practice what I preach, with that said on to pumpkin beer…

First up was the Post Road Pumpkin ale, not the best start we’ve had in a beer Brawl.  Beer lacked some serious flavor, but did have a good amount of spice.  Unfortunately there was nothing for the spice to hold onto to round out the beer.

Going Organic with the next beer, Wolaver’s Will Steven’s Pumpkin Ale.  This beer was brewed with organic pumpkin.  While it was a notch up from the post road, we still were not getting the pumpkin flavor that we were expecting.

Taking a significant step up in the rankings was the Dogfish Head Punkin Ale.  It was a good pleasant tasting beer, finally got a bit of, but not much.  We all felt this one held all the flavors together in the beer with out the spice taking over the beer, a solid beer all around.

Taking a step into the wild side, the final two beers were “imperial” pumpkin ales.  So you’d expect big flavors with big abv’s and that is exactly what we got…

The Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale was a crowd pleaser.  Big pumpkin flavors with some big spice and malt.  This is what were were all expecting from a pumpkin beer, but while one of the best of the night, still was not converting me to the pumpkin side of the force.

Finally, I think the beer I was looking forward to the most, the Southern Tier Pumpking; heard so many good things about this beer and how it tasted just like pumpkin pie.  Well, ahh…., it was not my favorite by a long shot.  However Corey and Mark did really like the beer, not so much for myself and Will.  The intense sweet doughy pie filling was not my thing, but Corey who liked this beer called it “cupcakey”.

Please Download the podcast and listen to all the details about how these Pumpkin Beers stacked up against each other. But if you don’t have time to listen, here are how we rated them:

Post Road Pumpkin Ale 79 82 72 81
Wolaver’s Will Steven’s Pumpkin Ale 83 84 78 84
Dogfish Head Punkin Ale 88 89 87 89
Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale 91 92 85 92
Southern Tier 80 89 87 84

Next week will be Oktoberfest beer part 1, a 2 part series and our first ever blind tasting! I’m working on future Beer Brawls™, we have Belgian Quads, and Trappist Ales Beer Brawls™ coming up. We’d love to hear your suggestions!


Tags: , , , , , ,

6 Responses to “Beer Brawl™ 25 – Pumpkin Beer”

  1. nate Says:

    The Weyerbacher came out on top…I suppose I need to sample a fresh bottle now to improve my relationship with this beer, after my bad experience with the shelf aged 2008 bottle.

  2. Simply Beer Says:

    it was pretty good, actually… for a pumpkin beer :-)

  3. Scott-TheBrewClub Says:

    I finally got a bottle of Pumking to try, but I think I agree w/ your assessment of the Post Road and Punkin’. I’ve heard good things about Pumking, so I’m slightly disheartened to see how it compared in this beer brawl!

  4. Simply Beer Says:

    Try it anyway, Scott. Like I said 2 of us liked it, 2 didn’t.

  5. JT Neville Says:

    Slightly off-topic but ran across the Fat Tire Hoptober, which was a pleasant change of pace from the expected Oktoberfest/Autumn seasonal beers.

  6. Simply Beer Says:

    New Belgium beer? Can’t get them in jersey… So how did they change up the fat tire, just souped up the hops?

Switch to our mobile site